Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company
Farm Insurance

Dufferin Mutual was originally founded by local farmers. Our board of directors today is made up of members from our farming community. We understand your insurance needs and have developed products to fill them.

Learn More Learn More
Auto Insurance

We offer the standard Ontario automobile owners policy as written by our provincial government. There are a number of discounts available to you if you meet the qualifications. We also allow for a discount if your home, farm or contents are insured with our company.

Learn More Learn More
Residential Insurance

Dufferin Mutual has packaged it's products to allow us to offer choices to meet the needs of your home and you. We consider each home individually, we look at the age of your home, it's location, type of construction and whether any upgrades have been made to the wiring, plumbing, heating or roof.

Learn More Learn More
Commercial Insurance

We have a range of policies to suit your business. We have grouped some of the most requested coverage into packages for your convenience. Our sales team will explain the coverage and how they relate to your company.

Learn More Learn More

Welcome to Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company

This organization was founded in 1895 as a farm mutual and remains a true 'mutual' today, owned entirely by it's policyholders, The headquarters are still in Shelburne, in the heart of the district it serves.

Behind us lie a hundred years of active service, and we look forward to many more years of growth and services to you, our policyholders.

Let Dufferin Mutual Insurance assist you with choosing the best farm, home, business and auto insurance to meet your needs.

Our Mission Statement

To provide our policyholders with quality insurance products using sound business practices while serving as a good corporate citizen.


We stake our reputation on settling claims quickly and fairly. As a policyholder of this company, you can be assured that when a mishap occurs we will be there right beside you to help pick up the pieces. You will also have the piece of mind knowing that your mutual has the financial strength and ability to look after you.


To report a claim please call our Claims Department at 519-925-2026


Emergency Claims Contact Numbers (After-hours & Weekends only):

Fred Temple

Residence #1-(519)-941-3696
Cell Phone #1-(416)-571-6352


Joan Scriver

Cell Phone #1-(705)-721-3210




We are aware of fraudulent activity regarding job opportunities for Dufferin Mutual within the United States.   We are licensed only in Canada with no capability of branch offices or locations in the United States.  If you are approached by someone claiming to be from Dufferin Mutual, we advise you to contact your local authorities.

A Proud Member Of Ontario Mutuals

Find a Broker near you:

Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company - Broker Locations

712 Main Street East, Shelburne, Ontario. Canada. L9V 2Z4
Tel: 519 925 2026 • Toll Free: 800 265.9115
Fax: 519 925 3357
email: info@dufferinmutual.com
© Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company 2012